News · Kalamazoo
Kalamazoo man whose convictions the Supreme Court threw out sues the city and two officers
KALAMAZOO — A Kalamazoo man whose fleeing and resisting convictions were thrown out by the Michigan Supreme Court has sued the city and the two public safety officers who stopped him in an apartment parking lot in 2019.
Douglas Prude filed the federal lawsuit Monday, Nov. 16, in U.S. District Court, MLive reported Thursday. He names the city of Kalamazoo and Kalamazoo Department of Public Safety officers Nicholas DeLeeuw and Nathan Belen, and he is asking for a jury trial and money damages.
The city said in a statement that it “just became aware of the lawsuit, but cannot provide further comment on this or any pending litigation,” according to MLive. KDPS declined to comment further.
What happened at Fox Ridge
The case began on May 30, 2019, at the Fox Ridge Apartments, a complex officers patrolled often because of reports of crimes by nonresidents, according to the Michigan Supreme Court’s opinion. An officer found Prude sitting alone in a parked car with the engine off. Prude declined to identify himself but said he was not a resident and stayed at the complex with his girlfriend, who was.
A second officer recognized Prude and gave his name. While the first officer went back to his patrol car to check police databases and the complex’s own trespass list, Prude asked whether he was being detained. When an officer said he was and was not free to leave, Prude started the car and drove off at high speed, the opinion says.
He was arrested on a warrant about two months later and convicted in 2020 of second-degree fleeing and eluding and of assaulting, resisting or obstructing an officer. MLive reported that he served about six months in jail. In the lawsuit, Prude says the arrest cost him a car that was towed and never recovered, and his housing, leaving him homeless after his release.
Why the Supreme Court threw out the case
On July 5, 2024, the Michigan Supreme Court reversed both convictions and sent the case back to Kalamazoo Circuit Court for judgments of acquittal. Writing for the majority, Justice Megan Cavanagh said lawful police action was a required element of both charges, and the officers lacked an “objectively reasonable particularized suspicion” that Prude was trespassing when they held him. His explanation that he was visiting a resident was not suspicious, the court said.
The majority noted the prosecution had conceded that the complex’s trespass policy “did not create, or form the basis of, reasonable suspicion to detain Defendant,” and questioned whether a private landlord’s rule could ever make an otherwise unlawful stop lawful. The officers could have asked him to leave and arrested him for trespassing if he refused, the opinion says.
Justice David Viviano, joined by Justice Brian Zahra, dissented. They said the officers were on a directed patrol in a high-crime area at the owner’s request, Prude was parked in a secluded part of the lot, was not with a resident and refused to identify himself, and that those facts gave officers reasonable suspicion.
What the lawsuit claims
Prude’s suit says KDPS routinely detains people at Fox Ridge over the complex’s visitor rule, which requires visitors to be accompanied by a resident, rather than for actual crimes, MLive reported. It also says the city failed to “adequately train and supervise its officers regarding the constitutional limits on investigative detentions.”
At trial, DeLeeuw testified he had been sent to Fox Ridge “dozens of times if not over a hundred,” and that visitors were regularly questioned, detained and checked against the owners’ trespasser list, according to MLive.
The claims in the lawsuit are allegations and have not been tested in court. For taxpayers, the case could become a test of what a city pays when a court finds a stop was unlawful. No hearing date had been reported as of Thursday morning.
Follow The Mitten Daily on Facebook for more Michigan news.
Sources:
MLive: Kalamazoo man sues city, police officers after conviction overturned (Nov. 19, 2026)
Michigan Supreme Court: People v. Prude, Docket No. 165664 (July 5, 2024)
More from Kalamazoo
All Kalamazoo newsNews · November 19, 2026
Kalamazoo public safety wants a name for the armed man who walked into a PNC branch on South Westnedge
The description is consistent across four newsrooms. The clock is not: accounts run from about 1:30 p.m. to 1:36 p.m. A department spokesperson says the reward is the bank’s.
News · October 23, 2026
Kalamazoo judges let many gun defendants out on no-cash bonds, records show. What Michigan’s bond rule says, and what the JAIL Act would change
Police arraignment logs obtained by WWMT show how often each 8th District Court judge cut the prosecutor’s bond request in gun cases. Michigan’s court rule starts from release, and a bill in Congress would let some victims sue judges.
News · November 18, 2026
Closing Kalamazoo’s psychiatric hospital would erase about 1 in 6 adult beds in the region
Dr. George Mellos says about 300 people are on the state hospital wait list. The company says about half the Kalamazoo beds are for patients with developmental disabilities. Medicare payments for new admissions stopped Monday. A license hearing is still in December.
News · November 17, 2026
Kalamazoo’s utilities director puts a combined water and sewer hike at about $5.50 a month
Baker expects similar increases for the next few years while the city replaces mains, lead lines, and plant equipment. A day earlier, a city memo was described as a $3.70 residential water increase. Those are not the same bill.
News · November 16, 2026
Comstock’s superintendent says staff cuts follow a revenue loss past $1 million
He tied the cuts to falling enrollment after years of growth, and said close to 85% of the budget is pay. News Channel 3 reported that he also said about 75% of Michigan schools are losing students. No list of positions has been published.
