News · Traverse City
Traverse City’s attorney says the parking fund must get back $7.6 million unless the West End lots serve parking
TRAVERSE CITY — Traverse City’s parking fund has to be paid back the $7.6 million it spent on the six West End parcels unless the land ends up serving parking, City Attorney Dan Kelly told city commissioners Monday night, according to 9&10 News.
“The parking fund has to receive back the value,” Kelly said. He said a development that serves the parking fund’s goals could reduce the amount owed. City Manager Benjamin Marentette said that guidance “does differ from the prior advice from prior legal counsel.”
At the same meeting, commissioners voted to introduce zoning amendments that would cap how many units on a downtown or commercial property can be vacation rentals. Commissioner Jackie Anderson cast the only no vote.
Two garage pitches and a repayment question
The city has been weighing two proposals for the West End land. ShoreNorth Development and Great Lakes Capital proposed a privately owned 534-space garage and asked for the parcels for $1. Endeavour Traverse City Partners proposed a public garage of about 365 spaces. A city finance review says a privately owned garage would require paying the parking fund back, 9&10 News reported.
Colleen Paveglio, the city’s director of communications and strategic initiatives, said a new deck would be paid for differently from the Old Town and Hardy decks, which were financed with tax increment financing. “We know that we won’t have TIF for these projects,” she said. She said planned downtown projects could remove up to 337 parking spaces and about $459,000 a year in parking revenue. City permits in the existing decks cost $45 and $55 a month, while developer interviews suggested private parking could run up to $350 a month.
Commissioner Kenneth Funk said he does not see support for another city-owned garage. “I don’t think there is a palpable appetite to have a city owned parking structure on the West End,” he said. Commissioner Laura Ness opposed paying for another parking study. “I don’t think we need a detailed study to tell us that we need parking,” she said. Anderson asked for a cost-benefit look at a public-private hybrid.
How the vacation rental caps would work
Vacation home rentals are whole homes or apartments rented for less than 30 days with no owner present. They need a city license and are already banned in residential districts. Traverse City has 547 licensed vacation rentals, about 6.7% of its housing, Planning Director Claire Karner said.
Under the proposal, each property’s limit would be a share of its units, rounded down, and any property with two or more homes could keep at least one rental. The cap would be 50% in the C-4a and C-4b districts around Front Street, 35% in C-3, and 25% in the C-4c, D-1 and D-3 districts. Rentals would be banned in the Industrial district, where none are licensed now. The largest group, 125 licenses, is in C-4c.
Existing rentals would not have to close. Karner said the caps would grandfather another 284 licenses on top of 93 grandfathered in 2021, and the limits would take hold as those licenses lapse over time. Anderson said she wants the caps paired with a separate licensing ordinance; other commissioners asked staff to bring back licensing options reviewed by the city attorney.
What’s next
The next West End session, focused on housing, is targeted for Dec. 7, and staff plan a deeper look at the parking fund’s finances at a study session, with Feb. 8 preferred, 9&10 News reported. A discussion of paving or graveling the lots for short-term parking is expected sooner.
Follow The Mitten Daily on Facebook for more Michigan news.
Sources:
9&10 News, Nicholas Simon, “Traverse City weighs $7.6M West End parking question, advances vacation rental caps,” Nov. 17, 2026, https://www.9and10news.com/2026/11/17/traverse-city-weighs-76m-west-end-parking-question-advances-vacation-rental-caps/
More from Traverse City
All Traverse City newsNews · October 31, 2026
Traverse City police are switching patrol cars to all-blue lights and high-visibility decals
The department says blue lights stand out at night and its new lights dim automatically to cut glare for drivers. Reflective striping and a larger “POLICE” on the back are part of the change, as the city buys two new hybrid patrol vehicles.
News · October 29, 2026
Traverse City Central High’s $25.5 million rebuild: TCAPS shows its new-gym plan as residents fight to save the 1958 gym
The bond-funded project has grown from $20.2 million to $25.5 million, mostly for accessibility and a single secure entrance. Renovating the old gym was pegged at $19.6 million. The board still has to vote on final plans.
News · October 21, 2026
Traverse City’s new attainable housing district offers small landlords about half the building tax for income-qualified renters
Owners of rentals with four or fewer units can now apply to pay about 27 mills on the building instead of the city’s 55-plus. Commissioners want a 15-certificate cap and five-year terms, and every deal still needs its own hearing and state approval.
News · November 10, 2026
Traverse City-area job growth outpaces Michigan and the U.S., an economist tells a Traverse Connect summit
Jeff Guilfoyle of Public Sector Consultants told Monday’s annual economic summit that the region’s employment is 9.8% above its pre-pandemic level, compared with 0.8% for Michigan and 4.4% for the United States.
News · November 5, 2026
United adds seasonal nonstops from Traverse City to Los Angeles and San Francisco starting June 19, 2027
Saturday Boeing 737-800 flights run June 19–Sept. 11, with select Wednesdays. The routes complete United’s mainland hubs from Cherry Capital Airport; tickets are on sale now.
